The surprise deal of Broadcom valued $18.9 billion to buy software company CA Inc. makes little sense on the surface. However, it signals a new direction for the tech conglomerate which will possibly be turning itself into a private-equity player.
On Wednesday, Broadcom confirmed it would buy CA , which derives just over 50% of its revenue from mainframe software, for $18.9 billion in cash, or $44.50 a share. The news was first reported by the Wall Street Journal, and shares of Broadcom tumbled 6% in after-hours trading. The shares of CA, however, jumped by 16% to $43.29 after hours.
The move is a new direction into software for Hock Tan, Broadcom’s chief executive, whose hostile effort to buy Qualcomm for $110 billion was nixed by the Trump administration earlier this year on national-security grounds. Broadcom at the time was based in Singapore, but it has since based itself back in San Jose, Calif., and the core of its original business was semiconductors.
Chris Rolland, an analyst with Susquehanna Financial Group, in an email, ” Perhaps it signals Hock is unable to find big accretive deals in semi-land that can pass regulatory scrutiny in this ‘new world’ (U.S.-China tensions or Trump’s influence on CFIUS/antitrust). Hock is all about buying defensible businesses with strong market positions and additional product pricing power, many of CA’s businesses fit this mold.”
Rolland also added that there are ample opportunities to modulate SG&A and R&D expenses in the deal to unlock significant free cash flow.
New York-based CA was founded as Computer Associates in 1976 to develop mainframe software. Over the past two decades, the company has grown through an endless series of acquisitions, much like the new Broadcom, and its business now includes a software-as-a-service business and other cloud companies. However, in fiscal 2018, just over 50% of its $4.2 billion in revenue still came from mainframe software, comprising $2.2 billion, along with $1.7 billion in enterprise software and $311 million in services revenue.
“CA’s clear focus on mainframe and other traditional enterprise data-center solutions and services could be appealing, especially if Broadcom’s ambitions include developing close ties with deep-pocketed large companies,” said Charles King, an analyst at Pund-IT.
He also noted that Broadcom appears to becoming more and more like Japan’s SoftBank Group Co. “Broadcom’s executives may simply be assembling a portfolio of sometimes unrelated yet still successful promising businesses, much as SoftBank has been doing.”
Tan told investors on Broadcom’s last conference call that one major criteria for future M&A deals is a company with at least an 8% cash yield. In fiscal 2018, CA said it generated $1.2 billion in free cash flow, up 11% from fiscal 2017.
“While it is difficult to see an exit strategy, the mainframe business can be milked for a very long time — providing a significant dividend to Broadcom — and the best of what is left might be able to be repackaged and sold as a rejuvenated new company via IPO or to another buyer,” said John DiFucci, an analyst with Jefferies LLC, in a note to clients Wednesday.
Now Tan appears to have broadened his sights to include looking at boring, older and possibly undervalued tech companies of all sorts, turning Broadcom into a player that may rival private equity.
However, Broadcom shares have fallen 5% in 2018, while the S&P 500 has gained 3.8%.